Peanut Butter & Jelly

31 Items
How would you like to shop today?
Choose Pickup, Same Day
Delivery or Shipping.
Deliver to 
Ship to 
31 Items

Peanut Butter

Save on Your Favorite Peanut Butter

Big Lots has low prices on your everyone's favorite brands of peanut butter. From creamy to crunchy, you can find the peanut butter you love for less. Peanut butter is a healthy and nutrition-packed spread that goes great on sandwiches, crackers, and even veggie snacks. Pair it with a tasty jam or jelly for the perfect PB&J sandwich!

More Ways to Use Peanut Butter

Get inspired with creative ways to use peanut butter outside the classic PB&J. With savings on peanut butter powder, you can easily incorporate it into a smoothie or protein shake. You can also find easy-to-bake mixes for peanut butter cookies, confections, and other tasty treats. Check out our recipes for more inspiration!